Chapter 17

Potential: Chapter 17 - Chapter 17

Counseling

Graham walked into Claire's office with no fanfare. He was focused and ready for a fight. Claire seemed to not sense the tension that Graham felt was infecting the air around them.

“Hey dude got that magazine you requested,” Claire said sliding it across the desk towards Graham. He gave it a glance. He had requested it last time. Graham gave a smirk. She had really played him, and like an idiot he had let himself believe the ruse. How could he have been so stupid? Maybe he was really starting to become a kid, he certainly was becoming naive like one.

“No thanks,” Graham said sliding the magazine back towards her. Claire looked a little confused for a second.

“Okay then,” she said shrugging her shoulders.

“I was thinking we could do something a little different,” Graham said. “Maybe play a game?”

Claire looked surprised.

“Well sure,” she said. “I guess that would be a good way to pass the time,” she said sounding excited as if Graham had finally accepted some sort of invitation she had been offering him for months. “What are you feeling? Monopoly, Uno, or maybe Connect four, Cody likes that one.”

“Actually can we do that word association one, you know with the pictures and the cards?” Graham asked. Claire furrowed her brows a little.

“You want to do one of those?” she questioned looking slightly uncomfortable.

“Yeah,” Graham said. “And I want to be the one with the cards, you can give the answers.” Claire studied Graham for a moment. He could tell that she could sense something was up, but she didn't know what yet.

“I guess,” she said retrieving the stack of cards out of her desk and placing them in front of Graham. Picking up the cards Graham began to flip through them. He found a couple and put them on the top before holding up the first one.

“This game is a little different,” Graham then explained. “When I hold up a card I want you to say the name of someone that it reminds you of. I don't need to know them either, just the first person that pops into your mind. Understand?”

“Seems easy enough,” Claire said sitting back in her chair. Graham held up the first card it was an octopus. Claire thought for a moment.

“Mrs. Leslie, my fifth grade teacher,” Claire said.

“Reasoning?” Graham asked emulating Dr. Grosse from when Graham had done his diagnostic test.

“She was also going a mile minute and it seemed like she was always juggling four or five things at a time. When I was a kid I thought she was so crazy for how she jumped from one thing to the next. As an adult I'm impressed at how she was able to do it all.”

“Good,” Graham said before he held up the next card which was of a golden retriever.

“Cody, definitely,” Claire laughed. “He's loyal and is always optimistic. He just seems to want to make everyone happy.”

“That's true,” Graham said placing the card down. “He's not always happy though.”

“Of course not, I'm just talking about the things that remind me of a golden retriever.” Claire said.

“Even golden retrievers can be sad once in awhile.”

Graham wanted to jump on the comment, but held back. It was too early to end his ruse. He wanted this to hurt. He wanted her to know exactly what he thought of her. He had chosen the dog card purposefully though just to get Cody into the conversation. He knew she would say his name, Graham would have done the same. As Graham thought on Claire's assessment though he bristled a little at calling Cody loyal. Was he really? Hadn't he gone behind Graham's back when he not only accepted Claire's brand of counseling and then wanting to continue it? Hadn't he promised Graham they were in this together? Graham found himself shaking his head. He couldn't blame Cody, not all the way. Graham then held up the next card. It was a wolf. Claire looked at the card for a moment.

“Chris, my brother,” she said.

“Reasoning?” Graham asked.

“He was always pretty independent but he was also pretty protective of me growing up. Like I was part of his pack or something.”

Graham nodded putting the card down. He felt a little sorry for Chris at the moment. It was too bad that his sister was someone like Claire. Poor Chris, the one person who was looking for him and she might have gotten pulled into the cult and might actually start to believe her own brother was better off in this new messed up life, that is if she didn't already believe that. Graham then held up the next card it was of a cat.

“Oh that's you for sure,” Claire said instantly with a little smirk.

“Reasoning!” Graham said a little flustered.

“Cats are slow to trust but when you get past that they start to show their true colors.”

“I'm not slow to trust,” Graham grumbled as he put the card down.

“You think?” Claire asked. Graham twisted his mouth up a little. “Maybe its just hard to recognize the animal we are most like ourselves.”

“Moving on,” he said. The next card was the one he wanted. Now was the moment. He held it up. On the card was a green snake. Claire sat looking at the card for awhile.

“That could honestly be a lot of people,” Claire said. She gave Graham a little smile as if to say “I'm sure you agree” yet Graham didn't return the sentiment.

“Wrong,” Graham said. “Just like you said maybe its hard to recognize the animal that best describes ourselves.”

“You think I'm like a snake?” Claire said with a puzzled expression.

“You aren't like a snake,” Graham snarled. “You are a snake.”

Claire sat expressionless. She then closed her eyes and placed her hands on her desk.

“Reasoning?” she asked.

“You know why,” Graham growled.

“That's not how the game works,” she said.

“You went behind my back,” Graham exploded jumping up from his seat. “You lied to me!”

Claire opened her eyes appearing stoic.

“I've done nothing of the sort,” she said calmly.

“You're counseling Cody again,” Graham said finally bringing his accusation straight out.

“Is that what he said?” she asked.

“Yeah,” Graham said sitting back into his seat. “Guess he let it slip.”

“So he actually told you I'm trying to get him to act more like a child?” Claire then asked.

“Not directly,” Graham said with a grumble. “Not like he has to though. Every time he comes back from your little sessions he's been crying. He's also been avoiding me and Zen, just to go and play kickball at recess.”

“I think you're jumping to conclusions here,” Claire replied.

“He said it,” Graham said through gritted teeth. “He said you were counseling him.”

“We've just been talking,” Claire said.

“About what?” Graham snapped. Claire let out a sigh.

“Graham you know I can't –“

“Yeah whatever you have ethics right?” Graham said with a click. “Give me a break. You're leading him along. Making him think that things aren't so bad, that things are better now and he's lapping it up to the point that he's now suggesting I try it too. Which is real low. Are you using him to get to me? Is that part of the plan?”

“He said you should try it?” Claire asked raising an eyebrow. Graham merely gave her an eye roll as he flicked his gaze to the side. “Then lets do it.”

“Huh,” Graham said letting his mouth drop a little.

“I'll do a counseling session right now just like I do with Cody and then you can judge whether or not I'm really doing what you accused me of.”

Graham was silent for a moment as he thought about the idea. Maybe he was walking into a trap, but would it work if he knew what it was? Perhaps it was a good idea. See her method, see how she manipulated Cody. That might give him some knowledge. A way to come up with ideas to convince Cody that this was all a ruse. Find a way to deprogram him.

“Alright, I'll play,” Graham said.

“Okay then so then we'll start,” Claire said taking out a notepad and pencil. “Whenever you're ready.”

Graham sat waiting yet Claire said nothing as she just sat looking at him.

“So what?” Graham said after a minute “We just sit here and...talk?”

“That's the idea,” Claire said. “We can talk about whatever you want too, and we don't have to sit here. Cody likes to lay on the couch, once he sat on the ground for awhile. You're in charge here.”

Graham got up going over to the couch. If that's what Cody usually did then it felt right for him to do it as well, just to make sure he was getting the full experience. As Graham laid on the couch Claire moved the chair so that she was sitting nearby.

“So now what?” Graham asked.

“Like I said we talk about what you want too,” Claire said.

“I already said what I wanted too,” Graham said with a huff.

“Then lets start with a prompt,” Claire said tapping her notepad with the end of her pencil. “Why don't you tell me about a time in your life you were really proud of yourself, it can be anything. Maybe from your childhood or when you were in college or even from you professional life.” Graham squinted his eyes without looking away from the ceiling.

“Nothing comes to mind,” he said.

“Nothing?”

“Not of the top of my head,” Graham said. Claire wrote something on her notepad. “What are you writing?” Graham then asked.

“Just some notes for me,” Claire said. “Nothing you need to concern yourself with.”

“That's not fair,” Graham said crossing his arms. “Its about me isn't it.”

“Fine,” Claire said. “I just thought it was interesting that you couldn't recall a single time anyone has payed you a compliment.”

“Why would I remember something like that,” Graham said.

“Most people like to hear compliments about themselves.” Claire then said. “You mean to tell me your parents never said they were proud of you or complimented you?”

“Those...weren't real,” Graham then said.

“Tell me about your parents,” Claire then said.

“That's not important,” Graham said quickly. Claire let out a sigh as she continued to write.

“You already know everything anyways, it was probably in my file or whatever.” Graham then said snidely.

“Not really,” Claire said. “All it said was that you did not have contact with them.” Graham found that interesting. Is that all it said, despite all the times Gretchen had told them they knew all about him. Once again he was seeing that this cult didn't have as much info as they claimed. It was probably one of their tactics. “Why don't you tell me more about your past?”

“Why would you want to know?” Graham then asked.

“We're talking about you,” Claire said. “There is no need to be so defensive.”

“I'm not being defensive,” Graham said. He found himself getting frustrated. There was nothing there to talk about. She was just trying to dig up old news. Weren't they supposed to be talking about his problems or something? His parents were not a problem in his life and hadn't been for a long time. “If you really want to know here it is,” Graham said definitively. “I told my parents I was gay when I was nineteen. They didn't accept that. We had our disagreements before about stuff but they waved it off as me being in college and going through a phase and that I would grow out of it. But when I told them about this they lost their minds. They wanted me to go to some religious group to like I don't know pray the gay away or something, I of course refused and that's when they made it clear that this was an ultimatum. Either do that or they could no longer support me.”

“And after that,” Claire asked.

“They took back their money, thankfully I had a job at the time that would help me cover educational cost. The last time I spoke to them they just said when I was ready to come to my senses they would be there to help and that they loved me.”

“How did that make you feel?” Claire then asked. Graham sat up from the chair looking at Claire with a look almost as if he had been expecting the question, it was the typical thing therapist said after all.

“I knew it was a lie,” Graham said. “They didn't love me, they never did.” As Graham spoke his voice cracked. He had never talked about it like this, not too anyone or himself really. “They always said they loved me unconditionally but that wasn't true...I didn't meet their conditions.” Graham began to sniffle. It hurt to say it out loud. It was almost as if by saying it out loud he was realizing it for the first time himself. Claire passed him a tissue as he continued to cry. “I don't understand how they could just toss me out like that. I was their son. They didn't even seem that sad about it when I told them I wasn't going to do what they wanted. I didn't do anything wrong.” Graham croaked. His words seemed to crack something in him, something he had avoided for a long time.

“That must have been very hard for you.” Claire said softly. “You keep trying to say that it didn't affect you that much, that you've made your peace with it, but I don't think that true.” Graham looked at Claire as he listened seeing there to be nothing to object too. “You've closed yourself off because you feel like if you let someone in they are just going to betray you again. Its not very healthy. You can't go through life like that.”

“You think I don't now that,” Graham yelped. “I did try. I decided to go on that stupid date and open up to someone and look where that got me. And now...” Graham became at a loss for words. Everything was beginning to fall into place. It was if Graham could see this conspiracy against him come into full view “I made myself the perfect target,” Graham said. Claire looked at him with some interest. “These people knew that no one would come looking for me.”

“I think that has very little to do with it,” Claire said as if she and Graham were commiserating about a bad business deal and that Graham's mistake hadn't been the thing to cost them the client.

“This is just great,” Graham mumbled as he hid his face in his hands.

“Graham I know its tough to talk about this, but you know this isn't the end for you.”

“What? Is this where you tell me I can try to build a new life for myself. That Graham Callaway doesn't have to be as much of a loser as Graham Hayes?”

“No,” Claire said slowly. “Its just that you've identified a problem that you can now take steps to address.”

“So what? I know now that I do have trust issues, maybe that's a good thing. I shouldn't trust anyone here anyways. How is this supposed to help me get out of here.”

“This isn't about getting out of here,” Claire said apprehensively as if she was thinking that her words would send Graham into a fit of rage. “This is about you working through things that are holding you back and becoming a more confident individual. This is about helping your inner self not about anything thing else.”

Graham didn't explode or react with any anger at all. He just sat feeling the weight of everything that had just come out of him. It felt to him as if he had just fallen into a pit and the sides were insurmountable to him.

“Like I said whats the point? No one is looking for me, I don't matter anymore. The only person that matters is Graham Callaway.” He couldn't believe what he was saying. But it felt true enough. Maybe this was it. Perhaps Claire had done it. She had got him to accept the truth of it. He couldn't be mad about it. She had played a good game and she had won.

“That's not true at all,” Claire said. Graham looked up a little surprised. “There are people who do care about you.”

“Like who? Gretchen, Gene?” Graham asked figuring he should let her have her victory lap.

“No, Cody does though,” Claire said. Graham shook his head.

“I'm nothing but a problem for him. A reminder of something he'd rather leave behind.”

“He talks about you a lot you know,” Claire said. “You guys may be having some disagreements right now, but I think you should know that Cody cares a great deal about you. You've been helping him in ways that you don't even know. He wouldn't still be here today if it hadn't been for you.”

“I thought you weren't supposed to say stuff like that?” Graham questioned as he felt a fresh round of tears bubble into his eyes.

“I think I can bend the rules just this once,” Claire said with a smile. “And he not the only person. You got me too. I care about you. I had lost hope before I met you. Seeing you fight everyday against the world gives me the strength to keep going myself. You're my friend and I don't want to lose you.”

Graham let out another shuddering breath as he wiped his eyes with the tissue. It felt good to hear that people did care about him. He had this all wrong and he felt bad about that. Claire was a friend and Cody needed him just like Graham needed him.

“I'm so sorry,” Graham whelped.

“What for?” Claire asked chuckling a little.

“I accused you of something terrible and I was the one with the problem the whole time,” Graham cried. “I just keep messing everything up.”

“Oh sweetheart,” Claire cooed as she got up and took a seat next to him to put her arm around her. “You didn't do anything wrong.” Graham accepted her affection as he put his head against her continuing to cry as he hugged her. “You did everything right, and now that you have identified a problem you can work on it. It can't hold you back anymore now that you know its there. You're a fighter, I know you can do it.”

Graham didn't respond as he was in no condition to do so. For a minute Claire sat stroking his hair as he settled down. A timer went off as Graham had stopped his crying.

“Our time is up,” Claire said.

“Yeah okay,” Graham said as he sat up taking in one last breath.

“Want me to call ahead and let your teacher know to give you a rest?” Claire asked.

“No, I'll be fine,” Graham said standing. He thanked Claire giving her another hug. It was strange the way he felt. She felt warm and the hug felt different too. As if it made him feel better, it reminded him of when he would hug his Mom when he was a kid.

Graham walked out of the office feeling lighter. For so long he felt like he was walking against the wind with no clue where he was going. Now it felt like he had something to go towards. He had a plan forward, now was the time to act on it.

Enjoying the story?

Subscribe for updates