Chapter 4

My Brother's Keeper: Part 4 - Chapter 4

Part 4

Adjustments

Thomas and I were sat on the couch. Davis was in the middle of a very long lecture. I wasn't even listening. I was scared though. Not only was I feeling like a little boy who was in trouble, I was also feeling the weight of my failure and what that meant. I had spent two long years building a level of trust with Davis, lulling him into the delusion that I was his good little son. Even if there were times I hadn't necessarily been acting it had all contributed to the grand goal – that was all gone now. We were back at square one.

“I can't believe you two, I was gone for thirty seconds!” Davis exclaimed. I shuddered a little. I was so stupid. Of course he had stepped outside to take a call. Our little victory had been false, Davis had been following us the whole time. He had seen us right when we stepped outside. Davis's phone then vibrated again. He took it out of his pocket. He rolled his eyes looking at the screen. “I'll be right back you two keep those butts planted, got it?” Thomas and I nodded. There was nowhere for us to run we all knew that. Davis walked out of the room to take the call.

“Whats up with you?” Thomas whispered after a few seconds. “Why are you shaking?” I looked at Thomas not even aware that I was.

“I messed up,” I said. “This is really bad.”

“Oh please,” Thomas said rolling his eyes. “So what, we got caught. Don't beat yourself up about it. He is probably going to spank us which will suck, but so what?”

“You don't get it,” I hissed. “He knows now that we are still trying to escape. That means he is now going to be keeping an even closer eye on us. That means we don't get any more chances. All that time spent acting like little kids is gone, he knows it was bullshit.” Thomas licked his lips a little as he thought on what I was saying. “I should have listened to you,” I said. “I just screwed us over in the biggest way possible.”

“Don't go saying stuff like that,” Thomas whispered putting a hand on my shoulder. “You can't be thinking like that. Charles, you're good with logistics and shit. I need you to come up with the perfect plan if we are going to get out of this. Don't worry about anything else. When he comes back in, just follow my lead.”

I wanted to ask Thomas what he was planning, but I didn't get the chance as Davis came back in. He stood in front of us with his arms crossed.

“Okay, here is what is going to happen,” Davis said. “You are both getting spankings and timeouts, so who is going first?”

“W-wait,” I stammered. I had to say something, try to salvage the situation. There had to be something I could say, some excuse that would make it seem like we hadn't been trying to run away. “I-I-I'm sorry Daddy,” I sniffled. Shit, what I was saying was out of real remorse I felt. Not for screwing up but because I genuinely felt bad that I had upset Davis. The feelings were too strong to resist. They were no help here.

“Charlie shouldn't be in trouble,” Thomas said jumping to his feet. “Its not his fault. I told him to do it. He didn't want too, though.” Davis looked at me the side of his mouth curling up a little as if he didn't know whether to believe Thomas or not.

“Well Charlie is that true? Did Tommy talk you into it?” Davis asked. I sat with my mouth open a little. I sputtered a little before looking at Thomas who was giving me a deathly serious look. He was telling me to take the out. He was giving me plausible deniability.

“Y-yes,” I said meekly. I didn't feel good about lying and placing the blame on Thomas, this had been my idea. However Thomas was showing that he knew the importance of me saving face at the moment.

“I see,” Davis said. He walked up to the couch and picked me up. He carried me to the corner and set me on my feet. “You'll do your timeout first then, nose in the corner.”

“But I just told you it wasn't his fault,” Thomas bellowed. “He shouldn't be in trouble.”

“Charlie made a bad choice by going along with you. He will be punished for that, even if it wasn't his idea.” Davis said. I stood in the corner with my nose in the corner. I don't know why Thomas continued to protest. He had done enough already. I didn't need to get off scot free. I just had to chalk it up to Thomas always wanting the best outcome. He was never happy unless he walked away with the best deal.

I was getting off far easier than him. We had learned that when we were both about to get spankings it was always best to go second. That was how Davis did it. The boy who was going second would do their time out in relative comfort while the one who went first would have to do their timeout with a sore bottom. After the other one got their spanking punishment was over and Davis would be their to cuddle and soothe the crying, well just me that is. Thomas never cried. Me? I couldn't seem to help it. My small body was more sensitive to everything including pain. Just one of the many ways that Thomas was better than me. I hated myself for succumbing so easily. But a sore bottom and the feeling of shame seemed to be the perfect mix to send me right into the arms of Daddy seeking out comfort.

“You know Tommy I've been really patient with you,” Davis said as I heard the sound of Thomas's sweatpants and pull-up being moved down his legs. “I think its time we address this stubbornness of yours.” Thomas said nothing. He never did. He was like a prisoner in front of the firing squad, a lit cigarette in his mouth.

As I heard the first smack ring out I felt a shock go from my spine up to the base of my skull. I felt my chest tighten. The second smack I could feel something. This had never happened before. With each swat I could feel something like vibrations reverberating against my back. My eyes went wide. With each successive swat I felt something so foreign to me. Its as if I could sense something changing. I couldn't really describe it accurately. I could only say on some level I could feel the world around me. With each swat its as if threads were being pulled and twisted around. On the fifth swat I heard Thomas let out a yelp. That wasn't right, Thomas didn't do that. By the eight swat he was crying. Davis kept on going. Thomas was blubbering for him to stop, telling him how sorry he was, calling Davis Daddy. The spanking lasted no longer than normal and Thomas was then carried over to the corner. I looked at Thomas as I was lead away. He was sobbing and red faced with some snot running out of his nose. No,no,no,no this wasn't how Thomas acted, never, not in a million years. I found myself across Davis's lap my own pants and underwear being pulled down.

“Daddy,” Thomas wailed.

“Tommy turn around and nose in the corner now,” Davis said firmly.

“I'm sorry,” Thomas blubbered as I watched him turn around. I sat in complete shock. As my own spanking commenced I didn't feel any of the sensations that I had just moments previously. In fact I wasn't even registering the pain of getting my bottom swatted by Davis's hand. Despite being focused on something far more alarming I still found my self sniffling lightly by the time my punishment concluded. My pants were pulled up before I was sat up into Davis's lap.

“Okay Tommy time out is over. You can come and get a hug now.” Davis said gently. Thomas turned around wiping the tears from his eyes as he came over to the couch. Davis had an arm around each of us holding us close to his chest. Both of us sniffling and holding onto him. The only thought in my mind was, what the hell had just happened?

“Okay boys,” Davis said. “I'm going to go get a late lunch ready and then its naptime,” he said giving us both a kiss to the top of the head before getting off the couch. I wiped my eyes a little. I looked over at Thomas who sat for a moment. He then slid off the couch. He looked like he was lost. I watched as he walked around the room a little as if it were a foreign place to him. He then walked over to the toybox in the corner of the room. He just stood for a moment. I was wondering what he was doing. He then picked up one of the toy trucks. My eyes widened as I watched him plop down onto the ground with the truck. He began to crawl around a little pushing the car along. He then stopped going back to the toybox and pulling out a playset that went along with the cars and some more cars to boot. I got up off the couch.

“Thomas,” I said with a shaky voice. He didn't react still playing with the cars. “Thomas,” I said louder. The boy looked up at me with a clueless look.

“What?” he said.

“What are you doing?” I asked shaking my head in disbelief.

“Ummm playin with cars,” Thomas replied. I went to my knees putting my hands on top of the car in his hands.

“You don't play with cars though,” I said. Thomas looked at me with a nervous look.

“I guess they looked kind of fun,” he said. Thomas then moved the car away from my grasp.

“Stop it,” I said. Thomas turned away from me.

“You play with them all the time, why can't I?” he asked scowling at me. I stood looking at him. His memory seemed to be okay, but he was still acting weird.

“What happened back there with Davis?” I asked. Thomas's scowl softened as he turned away.

“I got a spanking, same as you,” he mumbled. I shook my head again. That wasn't true. Something else had gone on.

“Thomas,” I said.

“Why do you call me that?” Thomas then said turning back around to face me.

“Its your name,” I said.

“Yeah I know, but no one else calls me that.” he said.

“You want me to call you Tommy?” I asked raising an eyebrow.

“Well yeah,” Thomas said with a shrug. “That's what Daddy calls me, and Ms. Kendall and all my friends.”

My eyes went wide. I had hoped that Thomas was playing a joke or something, but he wasn't. No way he would ever joke like this. I knew now Davis had once again used magic, I had felt it. I stood up and marched towards the kitchen. I didn't know what I was doing. I was fuming. I was mad at Davis, but mostly at myself. Thomas had jumped in front of a bullet for me and had paid a price for it that neither of us had considered. This was bad.

Thomas kept me level headed. He was strong enough for both of us. He could resist the change more than I. He said that was his job. He would keep me sane and I would keep the charade up. I had really done it now. I had given into an impulsiveness that befit my childlike appearance. Worst of all I had dragged Thomas down with me. I came into the kitchen to find Davis setting some sandwiches on the table.

“Hey, Charlie, lunch is ready go get your brother,” he said.

“CHANGE HIM BACK,” I shouted. Davis looked at me for a moment before giving me a sympathetic smile.

“You've noticed huh?” he said.

“Y-y-you brainwashed him. I know you did,” I said. I was shaking. I had never confronted Davis like this. I had no idea how he would react. Not too mention I may just be selling myself out, which is what Thomas had tried to cover up. Davis lifted me up under the armpits and sat me on the counter island to my back so that we were at face level.

“You think I brainwashed him, why?” Davis asked.

“Because he's acting like a...a –“ I stammered.

“A little boy?” Davis said finishing my sentence.

“Y-Yeah,” I said losing my voice.

“Well that's what he is,” Davis chuckled. “Whats the problem with that?”

“That's not how he acted before,” I countered. All ideas of facades was not important anymore. I wasn't going to let myself be gaslit.

“I did use magic,” Davis then said. I went to retort only falling silent when I realized Davis had just admitted to my accusation – he wasn't supposed to say that. “But I didn't brainwash him,” Davis continued. “I just nudged him in a better direction.”

“What do you mean?” I asked furrowing my brow. Davis laughed again.

“You are my inquisitive boy aren't you,” he said mussing up my hair a little. “I'll tell you, I've known that Tommy was having some struggles with his emotions. So I decided that I would help him along and just make it easier for him to let his emotions out. Its a natural process that you two have been going through. Tommy just needed some help over the hump, that's all.”

“I don't get it,” I said. “Why didn't you just do that from the start?”

“I didn't think I needed to,” Davis said. “You would have both gotten there on your own. You know that better than anyone.”

My mind was racing. I certainly understood what he was talking about. But there had to be something else going on. Why had Thomas been able to resist so much? I wanted answers, if not for anything else than to satiate my own curiosity.

“But why,” I said my voice cracking. It was a loded question. If Davis had known from the start that Thomas wasn't acclimating then why did he decide now to do something? Why couldn't I resist like Thomas? Why was I constantly shooting myself in the foot? Why, why, why? Davis didn't seem to get all the meanings of the question.

“Oh buddy,” Davis said wrapping me up into a hug as he lifted me into his arms and began to rub my back. “I don't know all the answers. But what I do know is that you were doing better than Tommy. I guess that's a difference between you two. Tommy can be really stubborn. But you are more sensitive. It means you are more in touch with your feelings. Its a good thing. It allowed you to be happy and carefree like any other little boy. Don't you think Tommy deserves to be happy too?" Davis then set me onto my feet. “There feel better?”

I nodded my head, I was lying, I didn't feel better about any of this. Davis then knelt down placing hands on either side of my head so that I was staring directly at him.

“I would never use my magic to brainwash either one of you. If I did that then you wouldn't be you. I just want you boys to be happy.” Davis's comment had no doubt been meant to comfort me and with how he was talking I knew he was telling the truth, it was a bitter pill to swallow. If I was truly still me than that meant all the childish emotions I was having were mine. I hadn't been foolish because Davis had somehow warped me to be. It was because as I was, I was foolish. A foolish little boy who couldn't take care of himself.

“Now go get Tommy, its lunch time.” Davis said. Sitting at the table I ate my pb&j sandwich.

“Aren't you going to eat?” I heard Davis ask looking at Thomas who had a sour look on his face. I felt a smile begin to curve on my lips. Thomas never ate right away, not before telling Davis he was a crappy cook. I was beginning to hope that for all of Davis's effort maybe he hadn't been able to completely change Thomas.

“I don't like the crust,” Thomas declared. My face fell.

“Eat your sandwich,” Davis said. “We don't waste food in this house,” Thomas let out a huff picking up the sandwich. He ate all of it except for the crust. He looked like he downright enjoyed it as he did. There were even crumbs and a little jelly at the corners of his mouth.

“Tommy I still see those crusts,” Davis noted.

“I don't like them,” Thomas mewled.

“Okay, then I guess we won't go outside and play on the swing set after nap time,” Davis shrugged.

“That and the crust are what make you grow big and strong. Charlie ate his so I guess you'll be okay with him being your big brother.”

“What, no way!” Thomas exclaimed as he looked at me with big wide eyes. He smashed his crust together into a ball before shoving them into his mouth. He took a drink of his juice to wash it down.

“Atta boy,” Davis smiled standing up. “Alright guys potty then nap. Whose going to make it to the bathroom first?”

“Me,” Thomas said hopping out of his chair giving me a challenging look before he scurried up the stairs. I didn't really have it in me to race him at the moment. I was drained and I felt even more sluggish then usual.

Getting into the bathroom Thomas was already sat on the training potty. I pulled down my pants and undies and took a seat on my own training potty. Davis hadn't gotten around to getting a potty seat for the toilet yet. He also said it was probably safer in case we had to go in the middle of the night to not be climbing up onto the toilet. It didn't matter to me though. Its not like I would ever wake up to go anyways. Davis collected our pants folding them up neatly on the counter.

“I'm done,” Thomas said standing up proudly as he went pulled his pull-up to his waist.

“Me too,” I said somewhat glumly as I got my padded undies back on.

“Good job,” Davis said. “That's two stickers for the charts,” Davis said giving us each a smiley face sticker. We went and stuck them on the charts with out names on them that were hung on the wall. We then walked to our room for a nap. I climbed onto my bed crawling up to the head of the bed.

“Charlie you look like such a big boy in your puppy undies,” Davis cooed. “Give me a waggle of your tail.” I waggled my butt as I looked back at Davis with a smile on my face as I giggled. A moment later I felt my face go red as I turned away frowning. Why had I done that? I quickly got under my covers. I had totally forgotten how mad I was at Davis. Truly I had the attention span of a toddler.

“They aren't that great,” Thomas mumbled from his own bed.

“Now now Tommy,” Davis said as he took a seat on Thomas's bed wrapping him up in a hug and petting his head. “There is no need to be jealous. You're getting there. Couple more days like today and you'll be in the big boy undies too.”

“I know,” Thomas said glumly. I watched as Davis leaned down to hug Thomas who wrapped his arms around Davis's neck before falling back onto his bed. Davis then gave him a kiss to his forehead and Thomas smiled as he closed his eyes. I felt sick.

“Ready to close those eyes?” Davis asked me as he pushed some of my hair to the side. Davis then hugged me I felt him letting go and only hugged him tighter.

“Please,” I said. “Just hug me a little longer.” Davis didn't say anything he just kept hugging me and rubbed my back a little.

“Its going to be alright,” he whispered. I just kept hugging him tighter. I needed this. I needed to feel whatever comforting feeling this caused my brain to create. I didn't care it was Davis that I was hugging. There wasn't anyone here that would judge me except for myself. And I didn't really care what I thought, I already hated myself. Davis tucked me in. I closed my eyes. Did I mention I was completely drained physically and emotionally?

Upon waking up I had the tiniest sliver of hope that Thomas would be back to normal. I looked over to see his bed abandoned. I got out of my bed hearing voices coming from he bathroom. The door was open. I saw a wet pull-up on the ground. Davis was knelt down next to Thomas as he pulled on a new pull-up. Thomas had a pouty face.

“It was just a little one,” Davis said ruffling up Thomas's hair.

“I wanted to go the whole day,” Thomas whined.

“Its okay bud, all in due time,” Davis said hugging Thomas. “You've been doing a real good job, so on Saturday you can wear the undies and try them out.”

Thomas's face lit up.

“Really, really, really. I love you Daddy!” Thomas exclaimed before giving Davis a kiss right on the lips. I turned my head away. Thomas was truly lost. Not even if he was putting on the biggest act in the world would he have ever done that.

“Wowza,” Davis chuckled as he got Thomas's sweatpants from the counter and held them out for Thomas to step in. “Someone's excited.” Davis then spotted me standing in the doorway. “Hey Charlie boy, have a good nap?”

I nodded as Davis used his finger to signal me closer. Davis then pulled the front waistband on my undies forward as he peered inside. “Dry as the desert,” he said.

“I get to wear undies on Saturday,” Thomas blurted out no doubt in an effort to glaze over my accomplishment.

“Yeah I heard,” I said paying more attention to stepping into my sweatpants that were being held out for me.

“We're gonna match,” Thomas said.

“Thats great,” I said. Thomas frowned a little but didn't say anything more.

Davis then brought us out to the swing set in the backyard. He didn't let us play out here by ourselves yet, not really sure why. The yard was surrounded by a white picket fence that we wouldn't be able to climb. Thomas was currently on the swings demanding that Davis give him under-dog after under-dog. I sat at the top of play structure spinning the yellow plastic wheel attached at the side next to the plastic spyglass.

“I want another one Daddy,” Thomas squealed as he soared.

“No more Tommy, I've given you like five already. You gotta swing by yourself,” Davis said taking a step back as he wiped some sweat from his brow. “Hey Charlie you want to swing, I might have the energy for one more under dog with your name on it?” Davis asked looking up at me.

“No thanks,” I said. “I'm steering the ship,” I said as I spun the steering wheel. He nodded. A moment later the neighbor next door was standing by the fence calling him over for a chat. Davis left us to go and talk to the elderly man. Thomas came to a stop on the swing and climbed up the play set to where I was.

“You wanna play pirates?” he asked. I shook my head instead going and sitting at the top of the slide preparing to go down.

“Do you not like me or something?” Thomas asked looking a me with a confused look.

“Why would you think that?” I asked. Thomas pursed his lips for a moment.

“Cause you won't play with me, and you've been looking at me weird all day,” he finally said. Thomas was probably right about the weird looks, although I hadn't been doing it intentionally. It was true that I had been pushing him away though. It had nothing to do with him. Or well...you know. I had no ill will towards the four year old boy Tommy that stood in front of me. I knew we were probably more similar now than we had ever been. Both of us powerless to resist are childish needs and emotions. I would be a hypocrite if I tried to justify my coldness down to no longer seeing Thomas in front of me. It was me, I couldn't face him without feeling a large knot of guilt in my chest. Somewhere deep down I somehow knew that if I could talk to Thomas not Tommy he would tell me not to blame myself. That wasn't a possibility though.

“I'm not mad at you or nuthin, its just something happened and you changed and –“ I said.

“I know,” Thomas said crouching next to me.

“You know?” I said as my mouth hung open.

“Yeah,” Thomas said in a whisper as if he didn't want to admit it.

“So you know that we were adults and that Davis isn't our Daddy?”

“I guess,” Thomas said. I smiled, I couldn't believe it. Davis's magic hadn't worked.

“This is great,” I said. “I thought he had messed you up or something. Erased your memories or something. We can still escape.”

“I don't want too,” Thomas said. “That was really scary what we did today. I don't even know why I went with you. I don't want to leave Daddy.” I did a double take from the whiplash of my thoughts. What was he saying?

“Why not? You know he's not our real Dad, we used to be adults,” I sputtered. Thomas merely shrugged.

“I just don't want to leave,” Thomas said. “All my stuff is here, and I wouldn't be able to go to preschool and play with my friends or see Ms. Kendall. I don't want to leave Daddy either. I could never hug him or play with him again. I don't want to leave him that would be really sad.”

I stared at Thomas for a moment. It finally dawned on me exactly what Davis had meant when he had explained to me what he had done. I knew exactly what Thomas was talking about. Davis hadn't brainwashed him. Thomas knew what I knew but he was now feeling the same feelings I often did, but they were probably magnitudes stronger than mine. The childish emotions were overpowering his mind, his adult desires couldn't compete. I was seeing what I would eventually become, this is what Davis had envisioned when he had said we would naturally acclimate. It wasn't that we would forget the past. We just wouldn't care any longer. We would want Davis to be our Daddy, we wouldn't want to run away. We would someday just accept that we were happier here. We wouldn't want to return to our adult selves.

“Thomas I'm so sorry,” I said placing my hand on the side of his head. “If I could I would reverse this. Make you able to not have those feelings.” I said becoming a little choked up. Thomas blinked. I stopped talking noticing his eyes looked different.

“Charles.”

“Charles?” I repeated looking up at Thomas with a look of intrigue as I pulled my hand away. Thomas's face twisted up a little before he shook his head. “Thomas are you okay?” I asked.

“I'm fine, and quit calling me Thomas.”

I cocked my head. I looked down at my hand. It felt tingly. I put my hand back on the side of Thomas's head.

“What's your name?” I asked. Thomas pursed his lips for a moment.

“Its Thomas,” he said. “How are you doing this?”

“Doing what?” I asked.

“When you touch my head its like I think clearer,” Thomas said. “Like I don't feel like a little kid.”

“I think I have magic,” I said not really believing it myself. It was true though. This feeling was familiar, I had felt it when Thomas was getting spanked.

“Don't stop,” Thomas said. I nodded. I didn't care if I had to walk around for the rest of my life with my hand on Thomas's head.

“I'm sorry,” I said. “Its my fault this happened to you,” I said.

“Don't be stupid,” Thomas said. “This isn't your fault. I've been pushing Davis for years at this point.” Thomas then paused before he looked at me somewhat embarrassed. “Its really not that bad. Honestly its the least stressed out I've felt in awhile. Is this what you've been feeling like?”

“Yeah kind of,” I said. “But you're way worse.”

“You really don't have to remind me,” Thomas said smirking. “But you know its kind of okay,” Thomas said.

“Dude, you kissed him,” I said. “Like on the lips.”

Thomas rolled his eyes. “Like I said you don't need to remind me. I did'nt mean I'm okay with this just that I'm not completely disgusted with how I'm acting in the moment.”

“Yeah I suppose,” I said. I really shouldn't have been bringing up the multitude of embarrassing things Thomas had done that afternoon.

“Charles are you okay?” Thomas then asked.

“Yeah sure,” I said. “Now that I got you back.”

“No, you look pale,” he said.

“I do?” I asked. I noticed I was starting to feel a little woozy.

“Its the magic,” Thomas said. “You're using too much maybe.”

“I won't stop,” I said. “I can't.” Thomas then gave me a gentle smile.

“You're going to have to.” he said putting his hand on mine getting ready to pull it away. “Its okay. Like I said. Its not that bad. I'll survive. Just promise me one thing,” he said.

What?” I asked.

“Tommy really wants to play pirates with you,” Thomas laughed. “Think you could humor the kid for a bit?”

“Yeah, sure,” I said nodding. There were some tears in my eyes as I finally let my hand fall. I sat for a moment staring at Thomas.

“You're crying,” Thomas said standing up. “I'll go get Daddy.

“No,” I said getting to my feet wiping away my tears. “C'mon I thought we were playing pirates.”

“Oh yeah,” Thomas smiled. Then that's what we did. We played pirates all afternoon. It was the most fun I'd have ever had with Thomas and possibly in my life. For once I didn't feel self conscious or hating myself for giving in to my childlike mindset. We were just two brothers playing without a single care in the world. I knew it was an afternoon I would treasure for the rest of my life.

Later that night after a bath and getting put in our pajamas I tried my magic again on Thomas.

“Charles you shouldn't be doing this,” Thomas said as I restored his old sense of self. “You should save it, you know.”

“Yeah I know,” I said. “I was just checking in, and making sure I could still do it.”

“I'm fine,” Thomas said. He didn't look like he was fan of me worrying about him. “Also thanks for playing pirates, that was fun.”

“Yeah, I had a good time too.” I smiled. Just then I heard Davis's footsteps approaching and I quickly pulled my hand away.

“So since nobody was able to check out new books at the library today we'll have to get something from the shelf,” Davis said going to the small collection of books on a shelf in the room. He gathered us together on my bed. He had an arm around both of us as he read from the book. I found the moment peaceful. I hadn't really thought about what the future was going to be, but instinctively I knew the plan had drastically changed. It was going to take time though. I might as well get comfortable with my life for the moment.

Thomas fell asleep during the second story. Apparently I had done a good job tiring him out that afternoon. Although I was very sleepy myself. I watched as Davis carried him over to his own bed. His eyes closed and head rested on Davis's shoulder. He was going to be okay for the time being. I had magic now. We weren't just going to escape, no, I was going to find a way to untangle this whole mess. I was going to save the both of us. I needed to. Not just for myself but for Thomas as well. I was his only hope.

Enjoying the story?

Subscribe for updates